Home › News › Puzzle: the one-disc edge move beats the corner

Puzzle: the one-disc edge move beats the corner

Published · By TG, the site operator

Ten squares are empty and Black is to move, with five legal moves. One of them takes a corner and flips five discs, and it is the move most players look at first. It is not the winner. The answer is a one-disc move on the top edge, the only move that wins under perfect play. The rules are the site's, and they match the World Othello Federation's official rules.

The position

Columns run a to h from the left and rows 1 to 8 from the bottom, the names the site's move log prints in capitals. The board can be turned, so go by the names.

8 ● · ○ ● · · ○ ·

7 ○ ● · ○ · ○ · ○

6 ● ○ ● ● ● ● ● ●

5 · ● ○ ● ○ ○ ● ●

4 · ● ● ○ ○ ● ● ●

3 ● ○ ○ ● ○ ● ● ○

2 ○ ○ ○ ● ● ● ○ ○

1 · ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○

  a b c d e f g h

● Black, ○ White, · empty. Black has 26 discs and White 28. Empty: b8, e8, f8, h8, c7, e7, g7, a5, a4 and a1.

Black to move. The legal moves are b8, e8, f8, h8 and a1. Which one wins?

Show the solution

b8. It turns one disc, c8, and leaves White five replies. With perfect play Black wins 38 to 26. The other four moves lose: e8 by 8 discs, h8 and a1 by 10 each, and f8 by 14.

In this position White has no move to a1: its legal moves are b8, e8, c7, e7, g7, a5 and a4. One winning line: b8, g7, h8, e7, e8, f8, c7, a4, a5. White has no move, so Black plays a1 as well, and the game ends 38 to 26.

The idea: the greedy move is not the best move

Taking a corner and turning the most discs feels strong, and a1 does both here: five discs and a corner. But it leaves White seven replies, and it loses by 10. After b8 White has five replies, and the corner is still there for Black at the end of the line. The guide explains why a corner stays put once taken; this puzzle is about when to take it.

The habit to practise is counting the replies each candidate leaves, then asking whether the corner can wait.

How the answer was checked

A script ran the site's own engine file, src/engine.js, and played every line to the end with no pruning. That took between about 51,000 and 86,000 positions for each of the five first moves. Passes and game over follow that engine's rules, as the official rules describe them. The winning line was replayed move by move through the engine's applyMove function. In two runs each, the engine's own move chooser picked h8 on Normal, a move worth minus 10, and b8 on Hard.

Try it on the site

The site has no position editor, so set this up in a game. Play the computer on Hard. When about ten squares are empty, count the legal moves for both sides. If a one-disc edge move and a corner are both open, try the corner, press Undo, then compare what each move left your opponent. The move log shows how many discs each move turned. Start a game.

Sources

Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.

All reversi news · Play reversi now