Puzzle: four legal moves, and only d7 wins by thirty
Published · By TG, the site operator
Today's puzzle uses this site's rules: 8 by 8, Black first, and a turn with no legal move is forfeited. The game ends when neither side can move, and then the discs are counted. The World Othello Federation's official rules say the same, and the guide covers the rest.
The position
Columns run a to h from the left and rows 1 to 8 from the bottom, the names the site's move log uses. The board can be turned, so go by the names.
8 ○ ● ● ● ● ● ● ●
7 ○ ● ● · ● ● ● ●
6 ○ ● ○ ● ○ ○ ● ●
5 · ● ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ●
4 ○ ● ○ ○ ● ○ ○ ●
3 · · ○ ● ● ○ ● ●
2 · · ○ ○ ○ ○ ● ●
1 · · ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ●
a b c d e f g h
● Black, ○ White, · empty. Black has 29 discs and White 27, with eight squares empty: a1, b1, a2, b2, a3, b3, a5 and d7.
Black to move. Black has four legal moves: b1, b2, b3 and d7. Which one wins by the most?
Show the solution
d7. It wins 47 to 17 with best play, a margin of 30. The other three moves each win by less: b2 and b1 by 14, and b3 by 10.
One line the search found is d7, a3, b2, b3, a5, b1, a1, a2. White's best reply to d7 is a3, and the board is full at the end. The margins were checked twice: by an exact search written for this note, and by replaying every line through the site's own move code, which gave the same results.
The idea: the winner stays off column b
Three of the four legal moves are on column b, beside the a-file, and four squares of that file are still empty. Only d7 lies in the middle of the board. All three column-b moves win, but each by less than d7 does.
We have not found a short reason that explains the result. The search follows every line to the last disc, and that is the rule to take from it: judge a move by where the whole game goes, not by its first reply.
Try d7 against the computer and see who gets the a-file →
Try it on the site
The site has no position editor, so this exact position only arises in play. Start a game and watch for the moment when about eight squares are empty. The site highlights the legal squares, so you can compare the four above. Undo returns you to your last choice, which lets you follow a second line. The move log shows how many discs each move turned, so you can check your counts against the solution.
Work out the whole line before you click.
Sources
- Official Othello rules — World Othello Federation
Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.